Time for a Base under siege story and the first story of this season to feel average, I think some of the reason it feels that way to me is that the Pting’s design undermines its threat looking very Slitheenish, maybe if it looked a bit more feral or dirty it would’ve worked.
I enjoyed the beginning on the junk planet as once more we got some nice interplay between the regulars and the idea of the hospital ship under attack is a good one but takes a while to get going spending too long on The Doctor moaning which could’ve been spent fleshing out the guest characters a bit more as they feel a bit bland.
The conclusion though works better than the last story with the two threats being dealt with in a neat way and yet again the show looks wonderful.
Five episodes in to get the first one I found average is a good batting rate as every series has the odd average story and average Who can still be bettor than a lot of other TV.
This was a story I liked the sound of before it aired and it didn’t disappoint as we reach the obligatory ‘bring the companion home’ episode.
Yaz gets to have a bit of development as we meet her family and it’s a nice change to see The Doctor just introduced as a friend and not some mad alien. It’s also good to see Graham’s grief being addressed and dealt with in a way that feels real.
The threat of the spiders is built up nicely and the scenes in the flat are nice and creepy including a grisly death with a few more to follow to help build the tension including poor Kevin!
The reason for the giant spiders makes sense and definitely makes the story feel like a spiritual successor to The Green Death.
Jack Robinson is a character very loosely sketched but one we all recognize. It feels like his story isn’t over, hopefully we get to see The Doctor lock horns with him again and maybe he’ll be a bit more fleshed out. The episode kind of fizzled out a bit with no big confrontation between The Doctor and Jack.
The episode looks as stunning as the previous ones, the show looks better than it has ever done, Jodie’s Doctor continues to impress me, she gets to have some lovely Doctorish moments showing her eccentric, compassionate and moral side, I really don’t understand the hate she gets, she’s playing a lighter Doctor than the Peter Capaldi but feels very simliar to both David Tennant and Matt Smith.
The ending with the four regulars was one I enjoyed, yet again it feels like four real people having a proper conversation with The Doctor treating them with respect and not just whisking them away, I hope we get a few years of this team!
Sadly today we learnt that Terrance Dicks had passed away and among fan websites and social media there has been an outpouring of tributes and I feel I should add mine.
My first book I actively bought was The Three Doctors, I bought it because Jeff Cummins beautiful cover drew me in and my child logic felt a book with three Doctors was bound to be three times as exciting and I wasn’t disappointed, Terrance’s prose drew me in and I was hooked on reading, I then discovered I had lots of books to catch up on telling me stories I never thought I would get to experience.
I haven’t stopped buying books since and all that is because of Terrance Dicks showing me that getting lost in a book was one of life’s joys. I know everyone is saying this but that’s because there’s a whole generation of fans who treasured our dog eared target books and I’m sure there are plenty of writers who started on their paths because of Terrance.
Also his contribution to the TV show shouldn’t be overlooked, his fingerprints are on everything over the 1969-75 period, along with Barry Letts he ensured Doctor Who would habe longevity and not just become a cult 60’s half forgotten gem.
Probably my favourite of his contributions was The Five Doctors, I was 7 when it aired and it was the most exciting story and even more thrilling was having the novelisation to read straight after, I can still quote huge chunks of it and it’s my ultimate Doctor Who comfort watch
So Series 11 is following the old pattern of a historical setting for the 3rd episode but unlike some previous stories we’re not being taken far back and it’s certainly not going to be the jolly old runaround we normally get.
The four regulars have settled in nicely and there’s some lovely interplay and moments of humor between them, it’s lovely to have three companions who feel like proper everyday people who just get caught up with The Doctor.
It’s good to see the episode doesn’t shy away from the realities of the setting or using the derogatory language of the time or try to pretend it’s all different now The reality of the setting makes me as a viewer far more worried for Ryan than I have been before and you feel Graham’s heartbreak as he realises he has to be part of the history on the bus.
Some people use this as a example of this series being “too woke” (whilst somehow missing the fact the show always has been) whilst ignoring the fact that this episode is never boring or preachy and is a wonderful piece of drama that just happens to have the odd bit of sci-fi in it and I think it will end up being one of the highlights of Jodie’s time.
Sorry for the delay, yet again real life intervened but don’t take it as a slight on the new series as (spoiler alert) I’m really enjoying it.
We begin seconds after the closing seconds of the first episode, another nice Hartnell vibe! It’s good to see The regulars thrust into a new adventure straight off and I loved Ryan’s reaction to being on a alien planet, it also gave Jodie a chance to be very Doctorish straight away on the spaceship, to be honest she’d won me over in the first episode but it was good to see her start to develop her Doctor more. I think Graham may end up being my favourite and gets all the good lines.
The episode looks and feels so cinematic, it still feels as epic as the Moffat era just in a different way though it’s nice that we seem to have returned to stand alone stories where the universe and timestream aren’t at stake every week, stories can feel just as dangerous for the characters without universal threats.
The story feels very 60’s in tone which is no bad thing, I can imagine this as a 6 parter back then with different settings each episode (and one of the regulars would’ve slept through the ship voyage so they got a week off!! ) The two guest characters get fleshed out just enough to keep you interested and don’t take away from developing the regulars, they feel like real characters and their reactions also feel natural.
The idea of a planet wide killing experiment also feels very Terry Nation too continuing that 60’s feel, maybe Chris Chibnall had been binge watching the first few seasons! I liked the smothering cloth creatures and the solution to defeating them coming from brains not brawn.
I did start to groan when they were talking to The Doctor as it seems to be setting up a story arc about The Doctors mysterious past and that goes against the new feeling of this series.
We end with The Doctor finding the TARDIS and whilst it’s totally predictable it’s a lovely joyful moment and we get the obligatory redecorated interior scene, I wasn’t 100% convinced at first but it’s since grown on me.
Also was so good to see ratings only slip slightly (Always going to go down a bit) and for the critical response to be so good. The anti-female brigade have got quieter each week with the exception of a handful of idiots. Jodie just is The Doctor already and the casting of a woman is a resounding success and I suspect (and hope) we will have quite a few female incarnations of The Doctor ahead
So finally after months of waiting Jodie’s Doctor has arrived and how refreshing that nobody barely knew a thing before transmission, I have tried to avoid spoilers every series but this was by far the easiest to do that, personally I think not knowing is a better way of viewing.
The episode opens with us meeting the new companions and immediately I warmed to them, they felt real to me and I liked that there were connections between them so they weren’t just three random strangers though sure it’s not just me that wished Grace was also going to be part of the regular cast.
Jodie’s entrance is handled well enough and she instantly feels Doctorish to me particularly in the sonic screwdriver creation scenes and whilst talking to the alien. I’m sure anyone who had genuine doubts about a female doctor have been won over (sadly the loud obnoxious male doctor only minority are a lost cause)
The story itself is slight but then that’s as it should be for a introductory episode, Doctor Who is full of homages and this time it’s the turn of Predator. The alien design is a nice one and wearing the teeth is a good touch and I have a feeling we may see them again, at least Chris Chibnall is keeping good to his promise that we get new monsters.
The show looks so good too, it feels very cinematic and grand in places though not quite as colourful as I maybe expected from the promo images.
Then we end with that wonderful new version of the theme kicking in, it feels fresh but so near to the original at the same time.
How lovely to have my favourite show back and on such great form, these next nine weeks are going to be fun.
So over the last few weeks we’ve had a lovely teaser during the World Cup, wonderful promo images, the comic con panels and trailer. It’s starting to feel like we’re close to the return.
Allthough I’ve looked forward to every series as it’s arrived this one feels so fresh and different. I’m genuinely excited like a small kid again and from the little I’ve seen I have a feeling we’re about to enter a golden age of Doctor Who. I’m feeling all this from the little we’ve seen, Jodie just feels very Doctorish to me and it’s been so refreshing to not have to make a big effort to avoid spoilers for once.
Sadly there still seems to be a small section of fandom who are dead set against a female doctor and cross the line in how they express this particularly to the female fans. It seems they’ve missed the central message of the character they claim to love. Hopefully they’re a minority who will shrink even more once the show airs and everyone takes Jodie to their hearts.